If you walked out of a Los Angeles courtroom with a jury verdict that felt insultingly low — or you won on liability but the damages number made no sense given your medical bills — you may have assumed the law simply offers no remedy. Jurors deliberate behind closed doors, their notes are destroyed, and courts famously refuse to second-guess a jury’s judgment call. But a published decision from California’s Fifth District Court of Appeal, filed October 9, 2026, confirms that there is one narrow but real exception: when jurors base a damages award on something the law specifically forbids them from considering, like the defendant’s insurance coverage or personal wealth, the verdict can be thrown out entirely.
The case is Martinez v. Contreras, and it is the clearest statement in years of how California courts handle juror misconduct claims arising out of auto accident injury trials. This guide breaks down what actually happened, what the court held, what it did not hold, and what a Los Angeles car accident victim should do if a verdict feels wrong.
What Happened in Martinez v. Contreras
The underlying case was a fairly ordinary rear-end collision claim: a plaintiff injured when the defendant driver rear-ended her vehicle on a surface street, with liability largely conceded at trial and damages as the central dispute. The jury returned a verdict that awarded far less than the plaintiff’s documented medical specials and lost earnings suggested was reasonable.
After the verdict, plaintiff’s counsel obtained declarations from jurors describing deliberations. According to those declarations, at least one juror raised the subject of the defendant’s auto insurance coverage, and the panel went on to discuss the defendant driver’s personal financial means — specifically, whether a larger award would be a genuine hardship for him personally — before settling on the final damages figure. The plaintiff moved for a new trial under Code of Civil Procedure section 657, arguing this was juror misconduct that improperly deflated the award.
The trial court agreed, granting a new trial limited to damages. The defendant appealed, arguing the declarations were inadmissible under California’s juror secrecy rules, that any misconduct was harmless, and that courts should be extremely reluctant to pick apart a jury’s deliberative process. The Fifth District disagreed and affirmed.
Why Insurance and Wealth Are Off-Limits for a Jury
California civil juries are never supposed to know whether a defendant carries liability insurance. CACI’s standard instructions tell jurors in plain terms to decide damages based on the evidence of the plaintiff’s injuries and losses — not based on who ultimately pays, and not based on whether the defendant personally has the money to pay a judgment. The policy reason is straightforward: a jury that thinks about the defendant’s ability to pay, rather than the plaintiff’s actual loss, stops compensating the injury and starts rationing based on sympathy for the wrong party.
That is exactly the concern Martinez addressed. Juror declarations described deliberations where the panel moved from “what did this crash actually cost the plaintiff” to “what can this particular defendant afford to pay” — a subject the jury was explicitly instructed never to consider.
The Fifth District held that where juror declarations describe an overt act — a specific statement about the defendant’s insurance or financial circumstances made during deliberations — and the subject matter is one the law affirmatively prohibits jurors from considering when setting injury damages, that showing raises a presumption of prejudice the defense must then rebut.
The Legal Standard: Overt Acts, Not Mental Processes
California’s Evidence Code section 1150 draws a hard line that any attorney investigating a verdict needs to understand. Jurors may testify, by declaration or otherwise, about objective facts: statements made in the jury room, documents brought into deliberations, or conduct that occurred during deliberations. What jurors cannot testify about is their own subjective reasoning — how a comment affected their personal thought process, what they privately believed, or why they changed their vote.
This distinction decided much of the appeal in Martinez. The defense argued the declarations improperly probed jurors’ mental processes. The court held that a declaration stating “Juror No. 4 said the defendant has insurance so it won’t really come out of his pocket” describes an overt act — a specific, objectively verifiable statement — not a juror’s private mental process. That made the declarations admissible under section 1150, which in turn let the trial court consider whether the statement was prejudicial.
The Two-Part Test Courts Apply
- Step one — admissibility: Does the declaration describe an overt, objectively provable statement or event, rather than a juror’s subjective reasoning? Only overt-act evidence comes in.
- Step two — prejudice: Once admissible misconduct is shown, California law presumes prejudice. The burden shifts to the party who benefited from the verdict (here, the defendant) to show, from the entire record, that no actual prejudice resulted. The trial court weighs the circumstances and has broad discretion; the Court of Appeal reviews only for abuse of that discretion.
In Martinez, the appellate court found the trial judge acted well within its discretion. The gap between the plaintiff’s documented damages and the jury’s award, combined with multiple jurors recalling the same improper discussion, supported the trial court’s conclusion that the defense had not rebutted the presumption of prejudice.
Think Your Verdict Was Affected by Jury Misconduct?
Strict, short deadlines apply to new trial motions in California. If you have questions about a Los Angeles car accident verdict, talk to our team before those deadlines pass.
What the Decision Does Not Say
It is just as important to understand the limits of Martinez as its holding. The decision does not mean:
- Every low verdict is misconduct. Juries are entitled to disagree with a plaintiff’s damages theory, discount subjective pain and suffering testimony, or find certain treatment unnecessary or unrelated to the crash. None of that is misconduct — it is the jury doing its job.
- A party can interview jurors however they like. California Rules of Court and the Business and Professions Code restrict post-trial juror contact; attorneys must follow specific procedures and cannot harass or repeatedly contact jurors who decline to discuss the case.
- A new trial is automatic once misconduct is alleged. The defense gets a genuine opportunity to rebut the presumption of prejudice using the full trial record, and trial courts routinely deny new trial motions when the misconduct appears to have been harmless or isolated.
- This opens the door to attacking any verdict a party dislikes. The misconduct still has to involve an overt act regarding a legally prohibited subject — a juror simply being skeptical, or weighing evidence in a way one side dislikes, is not an overt act at all.
How This Plays Out in a Los Angeles Car Accident Case
Los Angeles County juries hear an enormous volume of car accident injury cases every year, from fender-benders on Sunset to serious multi-vehicle collisions on the 405 and 10 freeways. Several practical realities make Martinez directly relevant here:
1. Insurance Information Rarely Comes Up Properly — But Jurors Sometimes Guess at It Anyway
California’s collateral source rule and standard pretrial motions in limine keep insurance out of evidence in virtually every car accident trial. That is precisely why jurors sometimes speculate about it during deliberations — it is an obvious, unspoken question (“won’t insurance just cover this?”) that nobody directly answered for them. Martinez confirms that if a juror voices that assumption and it shapes the award, that is a basis for relief, not something attorneys must simply accept.
2. Documented Damages Still Matter Enormously
The misconduct showing in Martinez was far more persuasive because the verdict diverged sharply from well-documented medical specials and wage loss. Plaintiffs’ attorneys in Los Angeles should keep thorough records — ER records, imaging, physical therapy notes, wage statements — not only to prove the case the first time, but to support a new trial motion if the verdict comes back inexplicably low relative to that record.
3. Timing Is Everything
Investigating suspected juror misconduct cannot wait. A motion for new trial must be filed within 15 days after the clerk mails notice of entry of judgment, or 15 days after a party serves notice of entry, whichever comes first, and never later than 180 days after entry of judgment regardless of notice. In practice, that gives trial counsel a narrow window to locate willing jurors, obtain compliant declarations, and prepare the motion. Any Los Angeles accident victim who suspects something was off about deliberations should contact their attorney immediately after an unfavorable verdict — not after the holidays, not “next month.”
What To Do If You Believe Your Verdict Was Tainted
- Act immediately. The 15-day/180-day clock on new trial motions does not pause for anyone.
- Document the disparity. Compare the verdict to your actual medical bills, future care estimates, and wage loss. A stark mismatch strengthens any later misconduct argument and is independently useful on appeal.
- Let your attorney handle juror contact. California restricts how and when parties may approach jurors post-verdict; improper contact can backfire and taint any declarations you do obtain.
- Preserve everything from trial. Jury instructions given, verdict forms, and trial transcripts of closing argument all matter to a prejudice analysis.
- Get a second legal opinion quickly. Not every underwhelming verdict involves misconduct, but a qualified personal injury attorney can tell you fast whether the facts resemble Martinez or an ordinary jury judgment call.
Beyond the Verdict: Protecting Your Case From the Start
The best protection against a disappointing verdict is still a well-built case long before it reaches a jury. That means a thorough initial investigation after a Los Angeles car accident, complete and consistent medical treatment, and documentation that leaves little ambiguity about the connection between the crash and your injuries. The same principle applies whether your claim arises from a freeway collision or a slip-and-fall at a Los Angeles business — juries and insurance adjusters alike respond to clear, well-documented damages.
If your case has already gone to verdict and something about the deliberations does not sit right with you, do not assume nothing can be done. Martinez v. Contreras shows California courts take juror misconduct seriously when the record supports it — but the window to act is short, and the evidentiary requirements are exacting.
Talk to InjuryAllies About Your Verdict or Your New Case
Whether you need help investigating a suspect verdict or are just starting a claim after a Los Angeles crash, our team can walk you through your options at no cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a California jury verdict be overturned for juror misconduct?
Yes. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 657(2), a trial court can grant a new trial when jury misconduct is shown by admissible juror declarations and the misconduct raises a presumption of prejudice that the opposing party cannot rebut. Discussing a defendant’s insurance coverage or personal wealth during deliberations on damages is misconduct because California law and the standard jury instructions bar jurors from considering insurance or ability to pay when deciding injury damages.
What happened in Martinez v. Contreras?
In a published opinion filed October 9, 2026, California’s Fifth District Court of Appeal affirmed a trial court order granting a new trial on damages after juror declarations showed the panel discussed the defendant driver’s insurance coverage and personal financial means while setting the injury damages award. The appellate court held the trial judge did not abuse its discretion in finding the misconduct was prejudicial under the circumstances.
Does every low jury verdict mean there was juror misconduct?
No. A disappointing verdict alone is not evidence of misconduct. California law presumes jurors follow their instructions, and a party seeking a new trial must come forward with specific, admissible evidence — typically declarations from one or more jurors describing an overt act, such as a particular statement made during deliberations — that an improper subject was actually discussed and that it was reasonably likely to have affected the verdict.
How do you prove jury misconduct after a California car accident trial?
A party typically obtains declarations from jurors describing what was said or done during deliberations, then moves for a new trial under Code of Civil Procedure section 657 within statutory deadlines. California’s juror secrecy rules (Evidence Code section 1150) allow declarations about objective statements or conduct in the jury room, but not about jurors’ subjective reasoning, mental processes, or how a particular comment affected an individual juror’s thinking.
What is the deadline to raise juror misconduct in California?
A motion for new trial must generally be filed within 15 days after the clerk mails notice of entry of judgment, or 15 days after service of notice of entry by a party, whichever is earlier, and no later than 180 days after entry of judgment. Because these deadlines are short and jurisdictional, an attorney should investigate any suspected misconduct immediately after an unfavorable verdict.
This article discusses a published appellate decision for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Case names and outcomes are summarized from publicly available court opinions; consult a licensed California attorney about your specific situation.